Jess Weixler

as Jillian

Jesse Eisenberg

as Tex

Jason Ritter

as Wally

Halley Feiffer

as Nancy

Keir O'Donnell

as Danny

Jocelin Donahue

as Paula

Whitney Able

as Dana

Matt Walsh

as Mr. Hightower

Craig Gellis

as Steel

Suzy Nakamura

as Neighbor

Jordan Davis

as Peter

Tippi Hedren

as Betty

Jennifer June Ross

as Penny

Madison Leisle

as Anna

Joseph McKelheer

as Richard Swinger

Choice Skinner

as Larry

Joe Nuñez

as Yani Perez

John Rosenfeld

as Joe

Angel Parker

as Joel's Mother

Jeff Sloniker

as Harvy

Abigail McFarlane

as Patricia

Taylor Vale

as Twin Bobby

Tanner Vale

as Twin Robby