Rachel Bloom

as Sarah

Vivien Lyra Blair

as Evie

Scott Michael Foster

as James

Sierra Katow

as Greta

Alex Jayne Go

as Nicole

Pam Murphy

as Margot

Kirk Fox

as Chip

Haely White

as Charlene

Micaiah Chen

as Stacey

Lennon Grace

as Grace

Tamara Perry

as Betty

Dewey Jamison

as Ollie