Tim Blake Nelson

as Marshall Applewhite

Vera Farmiga

as Bonnie Nettles

Simon Rex

as David

Michael C. Hall

Grace Caroline Currey

as Michelle

Jim Parsons

as Warren

Matthew Glave

William Mapother

as Reverend Applewhite

J.B. Yowell

Kelly Lynn Reiter

as Lee

Danielle Vasinova

as Louise Applewhite

Blake Robbins

as Deputy Willis

Jana Gallagher

Paten Hughes

as Karen

Molly Robbins

Jill Winternitz

as Holly

Layne Lazor

as Penny

Geoffrey Arend

as Kevin

Don McManus

Kaitlyn Kemp

as Terrie

Kim DeLonghi

as Ann

Randolph Parks

as Facody

Dominick LaRuffa Jr.

as Tom Ramirez