Michael Seater

as Brian

Emily Meade

as Suzie

Bo Burnham

as Tony

Brian Petsos

as Benny

Tim Blake Nelson

as Officer Totsch

Gillian Jacobs

as Lauren

Jeff Garlin

as Dean Theatard

Ben McKenzie

as Michael

Chance Bone

as Glenn

Gabriel Notarangelo

as Steve

Nick Bastounes

as Sal

Brenda Marie King

as Kim

Stephanie Kerbis

as Erica

Jennifer Monce

as Glenn's Girl

Billy Dec

as REO Monitor

Rengin Altay

as School Office Attendant

Carol Federighi

as Mom (voice)

Vanessa Bayer

as Superdawg Waitress

Hilary Anderson

as Hilary

Brad Morris

as Happy Foods Security Guard

Govind Kumar

as Shithaus

Barbara E. Robertson

as Old Woman