Laurence Olivier

as Priest

Julie Harris

as Maria (Priest's Mistress)

George C. Scott

as Police Lieutenant

Martin Gabel

as Chief of Police

Roddy McDowall

as Mestizo

Keenan Wynn

as Wine Merchant

Patty Duke

as Coral

Lou Antonio

Val Avery

Beryl Bernay

Santiago Burgos

Linda Canby

as Brigida

Leonardo Cimino

Frank Conroy

as Padre José

Steve Curry

Cyril Cusack

as Tench

Roger De Koven

Mildred Dunnock

as Spinster

Thomas Gomez

as Delgado

Martha Greenhouse

Rose Gregorio

Gerald Hiken

Arthur Hughes

Mark Lenard

Joanna Merlin

Jeremiah Morris

Dino Narizzano

Mildred Natwick

Tim O'Connor

Florence Stanley

Fritz Weaver

Louis Zorin

James Coco

as Soldier (uncredited)