Rachael Leigh Cook

as Erin

Sam Page

as Sam

Bailey Stender

as Debbie

Patrick Thomas O'Brien

as Chuck

T. Mychael Rambo

as Santa

Kathryn Fumie

as Maria

Rod Kasai

as Taylor

Mika Flanagan

as Olivia

Melinda Kordich

as Diana

Chase Marcotte

as Jonah

Jim Cunningham

as Lou

Sarah Agnew

as Mayor

Greta Oglesby

as NP General Counsel

Ahmed Mawas

as Archie

Agatha Rae Pokrzywinski

as Bakery Worker

Rae Dastoor

as Bakery Owner

Jake Leider

as Radio Intern

Christina Goltare

as Town Square Shopper (uncredited)

Gwen Ruhoff

as Elf Council member (uncredited)

Dawan Scott

as Tree Ceremony Attendee (uncredited)

Laura Judson

as Santa's Elf (uncredited)

Amy Jo Schmidt

as Elf Council Member (uncredited)

Lucretia Stillwater

as Angry Woman in Jail (uncredited)