Cate Blanchett

as Maggie Gilkeson

Tommy Lee Jones

as Samuel Jones

Evan Rachel Wood

as Lilly Gilkeson

Jenna Boyd

as Dot Gilkeson

Aaron Eckhart

as Brake Baldwin

Val Kilmer

as Lt. Jim Ducharme

Eric Schweig

as Pesh-Chidin / El Brujo

Steve Reevis

as Two Stone

Jay Tavare

as Kayitah

Simon Baker

as Honesco, Kayitah's son

Ray McKinnon

as Russell J. Wittick

Max Perlich

as Isaac Edgerly

Elisabeth Moss

as Anne

Clint Howard

as Sheriff Purdy

Rance Howard

as Telegraph Operator

Deborah Martinez

as Maria Nunez

Scarlett McAlister

as Captive Girl

Arron Shiver

as Rancher

David Midthunder

as Apache Scout

Sergio Calderón

as Emiliano

Ramon Frank

as Grummond

Deryle J. Lujan

as Naazhaao / 'Hunter'

Rod Rondeaux

as Hudlao

Angelina Torres

as Esmerelda Nunez