Della Reese

as Elsie Waybright

Teri Polo

as Melinda Mead

Kevin Sorbo

as Nathan Davis

Tamera Mowry-Housley

as Daphney Conroy

Lisa Arnold

as Mrs. Bell

Bradley Dorsey

as Steve Dalt

Tyler Humphrey

as Lucas Conroy

Jaiden Kaine

as Jeb Conroy

Toby Nichols

as Bully / Classmate

Izabela Vidovic

as Olivia Mead

Rob Boltin

as Mr. Brennan

Dylan DePaula

as Classmate

Natalie Hultman

as Becca Holloway

Brock Patrick Kaufman

as Joey Becker

William J. Wells

as Orphan Ricky Sanchez (as William Wells)