Paul Wesley

as Jake Tanner

Kaley Cuoco

as Blanca Champion

Gloria Votsis

as Keir

Torrey DeVitto

as Phoebe Hilldale

Jason London

as Mike

Cyia Batten

as Lee Tyson

Adriana DeMeo

as Daphne

Al Santos

as Luke

Nestor Carbonell

as Seaton Brookstone

Hal B. Klein

as Greg

Maitland McConnell

as Erin Gorman

Robert Buckley

as Nik

Leighton Meester

as Jaynie Hansen

Andy Fischer-Price

as Vance Carhartt

Bruce Bohne

as Coach Hansen

JC Chasez

as Ted Buckley

Jackson Bond

as Connor

Jennifer Murphy

as Mrs. Falls

Mike Lutgen

as Ral

Chris Carlson

as Sheriff

Lauren Sánchez Bezos

as Margo Moonhead

Andrew DiPalma

as Blanca's Scandal Guy

Joel Thingvall

as Hockey Coach

Punnavith Koy

as Hockey Fan