Steve Sandvoss

as Elder Aaron Davis

Wes Ramsey

as Christian Markelli

Jacqueline Bisset

as Lila Montagne

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as Elder Paul Ryder

Rebekah Johnson

as Julie Taylor

Mary Kay Place

as Sister Gladys Davis

Erik Palladino

as Keith Griffin

Amber Benson

as Traci Levine

Khary Payton

as Andrew

Rob Mac

as Elder Harmon

Dave Power

as Elder Gilford

Jim Ortlieb

as Brother Farron Davis

Judee Morton

as Noreen

Robert Lacroix

as Quinn (Elizabeth's Date)

Terry Simpson

as Dirk

Brian Patrick Wade

as Stacy

Kurt Hargan

as Stacy's Husband

Jason-Shane Scott

as Christian's Sublet

Daryl Burq Pearson

as Church Elder