Penelope Ann Miller

as Elizabeth Hamilton

T.R. Knight

as Mark

Blair Underwood

Anna Paquin

as Gemma

Charity Wakefield

as Jules

Amanda Christine

as Meli Goodman

Thad Luckinbill

as Oliver

Amanda Joy Erickson

as Rick's Hostess

Todd Terry

as Leo Cline

Marilyn Swick

as Upscale Patron

Scarlett Fernandez

as Young Jules

Walter Perez

as Rick Bream

Farah White

as Rose Chastain

Alyssa Gabrielle Rodriguez

as Kate Matthews

Calvin Williams

as Lawyer

Maria Alexandra

as Country Club Guest

Gracie Prewitt

as Young Gemma

Matthew Thornton

as Law Firm Partner