Jennifer Esposito

as Sarah Fischer

David Sutcliffe

as Fred Jones

Richard Portnow

as Lenny

Mark Deklin

as Erik

Diane Venora

as Brenda

Sydney Penny

as Chloe

Tom Clark

as Harley

Steve Monroe

as Stu

Donovan Dustin

as Henry

Stacy Barnhisel

as Michelle

Laura Ann Kesling

as Ali

Amy Cale Peterson

as Waiter

Sadie Stratton

as Lisa

Shalaina Castle

as Bride

Marliss Amiea

as Marty

Dougald Park

as Dr. Pete

Barry Ratcliffe

as Emcee

Don Danielson

as Groom

James Ball

as Jamie

Tom Howard

as Minister

George Wyner

as Charles Praxton

Katie Hein

as Rhiannon

Tonya Kay

as Tanya

Tico Wells

as Tim

Julie Brown

as Wedding Planner

Coco Grayson

as Young Sarah

Nathan Lindsey

as Male Applicant

Alyssa Preston

as Gloria

Michelle Castillo

as Meredith Sanchez (uncredited)

Mannie De Castro

as (uncredited)

Jimmy Heck

as Young Fred (uncredited)

Markeia McCarty

as Meredith's Friend (uncredited)