Frank Oz

as Grover / Cookie Monster (voice)

Jerry Nelson

as Mr. Johnson (voice)

Peter Linz

as Anything Muppet Boy (voice)

Lisa Buckley

as Anything Muppet Mother (voice)

Julianne Buescher

as Chef (voice)

Jim Martin

as Banana / Dog (voice)

Alice Dinnean

as Orange Juice (voice)

Fran Brill

as Cereal (voice)

Joey Mazzarino

as Muffin (voice)

David Rudman

as Milk (voice) / Cereal Girl (puppeteer)

David Langston Smyrl

as Mr. Handford (archive footage)

Ivy Austin

as Cereal Girl (voice)

Cheryl Hardwick

as Backup Monsters (voice)

Rick Lyon

as Cereal Girl's Dad

Richard Hunt

as Backup Monster (puppeteer)

Kevin Clash

as Elmo (voice) / Backup Monster (puppeteer) / Performer - "The Pasta Song"

Leon Redbone

as Performer - "Blueberry Mouth"

Martin P. Robinson

as Telly Monster (voice)

Annette Calud

as Performer - "Telly's Lunch"

Stephanie D'Abruzzo

as Little Miss Muffet (voice)