Drew Carey

as Geppetto

Julia Louis-Dreyfus

as Blue Fairy

Brent Spiner

as Stromboli

René Auberjonois

as Prof Buonragazzo

Seth Adkins

as Pinocchio

Usher

as Ring Leader

Ana Gasteyer

as Sra Giovanni

Wayne Brady

as The Magician

Christopher Rodriguez Marquette

as Featured (as Christopher Marquette)

Anton Yelchin

as Featured

Myles Jeffrey

as Featured

Taylor Emerson

as Featured

Kyle Sullivan

as Featured

Dennis Bendersky

as Featured

Sara Paxton

as Featured

Kane Hodder

as Pleasure Island Inhabitant

Renee Olstead

as Perfect Child