Melissa Joan Hart

as Sabrina / Sophie

Eddie Mills

as Paul

Tara Strong

as Gwen

James Fields

as Travis

Eric Alexander

as Alberto

Nick Bakay

as Salem Saberhagen (voice)

Richard Steven Horvitz

as Stonehenge (voice)

Francesco Mazzini

as Mercutio

Evelyn Furtak

as Mrs. Guadagno

Robert Steiner

as Roberto

Stefano Maria Mioni

as Taxi Driver

Paolo Giovannucci

as Statue of David