David Bowles

as Waiter

James Eckhouse

as Dr. Doctor Willard Bliss

Kathryn Erbe

as Lucretia Garfield

Ladislav Gergel

as Jim Garfield

Shuler Hensley

as James Garfield

Logan Hillier

as Dr. Reyburn

John Hutton

as James Blaine

Will Janowitz

as Charles Guiteau

Josef Karas

as Conkling's Valet

Adam LeFevre

as Chester Arthur

Sean Mahon

as Roscoe Conkling

Michael Murphy

as Narrator

Ted Otis

as Reporter

Daniel Pearce

as Silas Boynton

Karina Rchichev

as Mary 'Mollie' Garfield

Dan Rowland

as Harry Garfield

Joe Weintraub

as Joseph Stanley Brown