Sofe Cote

as Margaret East

Chandani Smith

as Jesus Christ

Sara Kaiser

as May West

Max Husten

as Caleb / The Information Man

Robert Prichard

as Elmer East

Fritz Donnelly

as Barnaby

Lucy Love

as Sodia East

Mickala McFarlane

as Rosaria, a Dancer

Lloyd Kaufman

as Vice President Cliff Kaufman

Savvy Jaye

as Savvy

Allysa Oliver

as Ollie the Sado

Stephanie Domini

as Mary

Amanda Flowers

as Queen Sodia

Kate Freitag

as Katie the Sado

Mac DeMarco

as The Master

Reverend Jen Miller

John Patrick Brennan

Dylan Mars Greenberg

as Marli Deetrich