Anjelica Huston

as Maggie

Bill Pullman

as Ben

David Morse

as Gerry

Julia Stiles

as Rachel

Brian d'Arcy James

as Logan

Jim Parrack

as Curt

Victor Williams

as Ray

Annie Q. Riegel

as Elise

Isidora Goreshter

as Young Maggie

Jake Katzman

as Young Gerry

Michael Oberholtzer

as Young Ben

Demosthenes Chrysan

as Josh

Myrna Cabello

Eli Golden

Julia Antonelli

as Young Maggie

Mandi Masden

as Sarah

Hubert Point-Du Jour

as Dr. Adunbi

Susannah Rogers

as Elaine

Michelle Santiago

as Bar Patron

Debargo Sanyal

as James