Jenna Fischer

as Laura

Chris O'Donnell

as Bob

Kim Coates

as Mel Kaminsky

Lesley Ann Warren

as Joan

Sara Kapner

as Wendy Helms

Brooke Smith

as Kathy Helms

Daniel Yelsky

as Dennis Pehlke

Jay Klaitz

as Patient

Rob Benedict

as Paul Helms

Zach Page

as Kyle Helms

Sarah Wilson

as Amanda

Sam McMurray

as Big Bad Dan

James Rebhorn

as Dr. Bronstein

Joy Suprano

as Julie Cantoni

Ron Leibman

as Warren Dunning

Michelle Hurst

as Eileen

Matt Oberg

as Minister

Douglas Lipman

as Doug

Carla Briscoe

as Kristen

Elaine Kussack

as Sara

Brandon Perler

as Noah

Miles Williams

as Christopher

Arden Myrin

as Ms. Gallagher

Nadia Dajani

as Angela Behar

Gracie Lawrence

as Gracie

Dion DiMucci

as Dion

Jim Florentine

as Brian Markland

Kristen Boulé

as Waitress

Lynn Cohen

as Mrs. Cosolito

Shari Albert

as Rhonda

Aida Turturro

as Nancy Feldman

Jacob Levine

as Seth Feldman

Millie Trachtenberg

as Scornful Parent