Robert Wagner

as Gilbert Barrows

Dolores Hart

as Elinor Harrison

Ernie Kovacs

as Bugsy G. Foglemeyer aka The Captain

Frankie Avalon

as Ens. Rodney J. Foglemeyer

Frank Gorshin

as George M. Wilson

Harvey Lembeck

as Nickels

Sid Tomack

as Sammy

Guy Raymond

as Helmut

Buck Kartalian

as Finster

Wilton Graff

as Simon J. Harrison

Marjorie Bennett

as Mrs. Chowder

Carolyn Jones

as Virginia

Jesse White

as McDonald

Hal Taggart

as Pilgrim at Turkey Giveaway

Hope Sansberry

as Biddy

Howard Wendell

as Mr. Caldingham (uncredited)

Hal Taggart

as Pilgrim at Turkey Giveaway (uncredited)

Tom Symonds

as Second Man (uncredited)

Robert Stevenson

as Coast Guard Officer (uncredited)

Cosmo Sardo

as Man in Bank (uncredited)

Hope Sansberry

as Biddy (uncredited)

Bru Mysak

as Newsboy (uncredited)

Terry Huntingdon

as Young Lady Pilgrim (uncredited)

Graeme Ferguson

as First Man (uncredited)