Jance Enslin

as Andy Cady

Carly Pope

as Angela Cady

Alyssa Sutherland

as Dana Cady

Alison Thornton

as Bethany Forrest

Bryan Greenberg

as Dylan Cady

William R. Moses

as Principal Mullins

Michael Gladis

as Michael Kennedy

Jim True-Frost

as Pastor Shane

William Popp

as Deputy Johnson

Remington Moses

as Melanie Hansen

Blaine Maye

as Brian Ward

Allen Wall

as Freak at the Carnival

Scott Matheny

as State Trooper

Quinn Hemphill

as Amber Ryan

Bernie Sheredy

as Dr. Roger Wagner

Dannielle Rose

as Religious Woman

Nathan Wallace

as Paul Winters

Amber Anne

as Church Choir / Swim Team

Kevin A. Wall

as Carnival Freak

Daniel Rayome

as Fairgoer

Nolan Callahan

as Lifeguard / student

Michael Barbour

as Sheriff Dell