Jillian Lebling

as Elayna (segment "Until Forever")

Ben Shaul

as Adriano (segment "Until Forever")

Elohim Peña

as Kerry Reynosa

Steven Alonte

as Charles / Psychopomp

Kulani Kai

as Evelyn Reynosa

Jay Rattle

as Obed (segment "Until Forever)

Reinhold Von Bolt

as Gabriel (segment "Until Forever)

Coda Marcus

as Ivan (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")

Olivia Tennison

as Mel (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")

Easton Michaels

as Lonny (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")

Byron Daniel Bishop

as Principal Dennings (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")

Peter Knox

as Carl Crimwood (Segment "Answers")

Katelin Stack

as Rosemary

Dan Davies

as Detective Scott Redmayne (segment "Answers")

H. Adoni Esho

as Detective Ashur Nassar (Segment "Answers")

Danny Villanueva Jr.

as Julian Torres

Beth Johnson

as Dolores Valentine

Fiona Rose Dyer

as Caroline (segment "Spellbound High Monster Hop")