Frankie Muniz

as Justin Yoder

Rick Rossovich

as Myron Yoder

Molly Hagan

as Sheila Yoder

Patrick Levis

as Seth Yoder

Roger Aaron Brown

as Vic Sauder

Tuc Watkins

as God / Bobby Wade

Brittany Paige Bouck

as Cindy

Todd Hurst

as Brad

Kara Keough

as Teresa Guntman

Joel McKinnon Miller

as Bill Guntman

Holmes Osborne

as Randall

Freda Foh Shen

as Dr. Kwan

Christian Copelin

as Pipsqueak

Judith Drake

as Volunteer

Rick Fitts

as Soccer Coach

Jim Jansen

as Minister

James Lashly

as Leather Jacket Man

Tom Nolan

as Baseball Coach

Milt Tarver

as Elder Statesman

Tom Virtue

as Announcer