Phil Brooks

as CM Punk

Nuufolau Joel Seanoa

as Samoa Joe

Nelson Rodriguez Erazo

as Homicide

Oren Hawxhurst

as Altar Boy Luke

Kirby Marcos

as Marcos

Matt Knowles

as Loc

Diablo Santiago

Danny Lopez

as Dan Maff

Michael Verdi

as Trent Acid

Jack Miller

as Jack Evans

Benjamin Whitmer

as BJ Whitmer

John Stagikas

as John Walters

Doug Durdle

as Doug Williams

Rick Diaz

as Ricky Reyes

John Raymond Rivera

as Rocky Romero

Scott Colton

as Colt Cabana

Daniel Solwold Jr.

as Austin Aries

Christopher Guy

Christopher Lindsey

as Roderick Strong

James Guffey

as Jimmy Rave

Patrick Martin

as Alex Shelley

Jamar Shipman

as Jay Lethal

Walter Kirney

as Angel Dust