Rashida Jones

as Celeste Martin

Andy Samberg

as Jesse Abrams

Ari Graynor

as Beth

Eric Christian Olsen

as Tucker

Chris Messina

as Paul

Emma Roberts

as Riley Banks

Elijah Wood

as Scott

Rebecca Dayan

as Veronica

Janel Parrish

as Savannah

Sarah Haskins

as Parent

Matthew Del Negro

as Nick

Shira Lazar

as Herself

Will McCormack

as Skillz

Kate Krieger

as Yogurt Girl

Chris Pine

as Rory Shenandoah

Zoë Hall

as Waitress

Lenny Jacobson

as Peter Pan

Chris D'Elia

as Snow White

Lauren Sánchez Bezos

as News Reporter

Robert Kya-Hill

as Priest

Sarah Wright

as Bridesmaid

Rob Huebel

as Man Who Cuts In Line

Rafi Gavron

as Rupert

Jason Antoon

as Man in Convenience Store

Rich Sommer

as Max