James Pumphrey

as Fitz

Abby Elliott

as Monica

Dylan O'Brien

as Jimmy Malone

Lizzy Caplan

as Sheila

Rich Fulcher

as Arnie

Matt Jones

as Richie

Joe Lo Truglio

as Officer Fogerty

Rob Riggle

as James Malone Sr.

Horatio Sanz

as Doctor

Zach Woods

as Tommy

Brandon Johnson

as Cab Driver

Andy Daly

as Mr. Doobin

Kathryn Burns

as Orchid

Mike Coleman

as Bakersfield Bouncer

Kyle Gass

as Winter Wierdo

Curtis Gwinn

as Tow Truck Driver

Ed Helms

as Barry