Sydney Hirsch

as Charlotte

Zac Amico

as The Bottom Butcher

Ian Fidance

as Artie Fambuglio

Johnny Ferri

as Brack/Joey Carbone

Amanda Flowers

as Jennifer Roth

Marcus Bishop-Wright

as Therapist/Father Tomas/Lt. Finch

Jaime Lutz

as Det. Cabot

Billy Bob Thompson

as Greggie

Jen Elyse Feldy

as Tara

Kelly Polk

as PJ

Rachel Francis

as Harmony

Conor McCarthy

as Johnnie Lee

Bimini Lee-Wright

as Claudette

Pat Foy

as Sam

Jean Louise O'Sullivan

as Ruby

Abraham Sparrow

as Houseman

Steph Shober

as Dr. Sara Carmichael

Dominick Denaro

as Lil Tony Damante

Lloyd Kaufman

as The Mad Monk/Narrator

Teresa Hui

as Sister May

Dylan Mars Greenberg

as Caroline Menders

Lisa Gaye

as Sister Anne

Heather Sprow

as Angie

Lou Perez

as Gio

Alan Ceppos

as Walter Dahnger

Vito Trigo

as Father O'Donelly

Seby X. Martinez

as Walter Dahnger III

Doug Sakmann

as Goon #1

Polly Jean Bassham

as Young Jennifer