Robert Stack

as Jim Holliday

Ann Rutherford

as Anne Grayson

Broderick Crawford

as Bob Holliday

Frances Farmer

as Calamity Jane

Lon Chaney Jr.

as Jack McCall

Richard Dix

as James Butler "Wild Bill" Hickok

Andy Devine

as Spearfish

Hugh Herbert

as Rocky Plummer

Fuzzy Knight

as Hurricane Harry

Bradley Page

as Jesse Chapman

Dwight Latham

as Member, The Jesters

Walter Carlson

as Member, The Jesters

Guy Bonham

as Member, The Jesters

Addison Richards

as Gen. George Custer

Willie Fung

as Wong Lee

Richard Alexander

as Coach Driver with Rifle

Don Barclay

as Joe

Robert Barron

as Gambler

Hank Bell

as Townsman

Al Bridge

as Plainview Lawman

Jean Brooks

as Bella Union Girl

Paul Bryar

as Barfly

John Cason

as Townsman

Rube Dalroy

as Townsman

Harry Cording

as Jackson

Eddie Dew

as Henchman

Jim Farley

as Councilman

Edward Fielding

as Councilman

Samuel S. Hinds

as Wilbur Grayson

Charles King

as Plainview Gunman

Joe King

as Ship's Captain

Ethan Laidlaw

as Gambler

Kermit Maynard

as Poker Player

Chuck Morrison

as Henchman

Clinton Rosemond

as Grayson's Butler

William Ruhl

as Ship's Officer

Carl Sepulveda

as Barfly

Glenn Strange

as Bob Russell

Emmett Vogan

as Ransome

Nolan Willis

as Plainview Gunman

Carleton Young

as Ben Mercer