Phil Brooks

as CM Punk

Nuufolau Joel Seanoa

Scott Colton

as Colt Cabana

Salvatore Rinauro

as Sal Rinauro

Nelson Rodriguez Erazo

as Homicide

Walter Kirney

as Azrieal

Christopher Lindsey

as Roderick Strong

Charles Spencer

as Tony Mamaluke

Eddie Villa

as "Fast" Eddie Vegas

Jay Fury

as Jay Fury

Kory Chavis

as Rainman

Edward Walker

as Vordell Walker

Evan Starsmore

as Evan Starsmore

Steve Favata

as Steve Madison

Aaron Epic

as Aaron Epic

Phil Davis

as "Fabulous" Phil Davis

Sean Davis

as "Superstar" Sean Davis

Chris Valenzuela

as Don Juan

Chris Marvel

as Chris Marvel

Jerrelle Clark

as Jerrelle Clark

Jared Steele

as Jared Steele

Dave Prazak

as Dave Prazak (Manager)